Kevin O'Toole

NYC

• #22 • Left Back

Kevin O'Toole

NYC

• #22 • Left Back

Nationality

Republic of Ireland

Position

Role

Possession Builder

Birthdate (Age)

Dec 14, 1998 (27)

Preferred Foot

Left

Height

5'10"

Weight

150 lb

Club

New York City

League

Major League Soccer

Ranking

Major League Soccer

2026 All matches

Overall grade

331/701

Impact score

6.2

344/701

Defender rank

159th

159/281

All rank

405th

405/701

Grades

Key Grades

2026 Major League Soccer

Overall

135th/287 DEF

Passing

76th/287 DEF

70.8

Crossing

37th/216 DEF

Ball Carrying

195th/251 DEF

58.8

1 V 1 Defending

148th/281 DEF

65.7

Positioning

192nd/284 DEF

63.3

Overall Grades by game

2026 Major League Soccer

Metrics

Key Metrics

2026 Major League Soccer

Appearances

905

Minutes

Goals

Assists

Upcoming matches

TQL Stadium • MLS Pass on Apple TV

Boston Stadium • MLS Pass on Apple TV

News

May 21, 2026

Ruled out after surgery

O'Toole is sidelined for the time being following a procedure on his groin and abdomen, according to his club.

Analysis: O'Toole won't play at least until after the World Cup break while the exact severity of his problems remains unclear. The left-back was initially a consistent starter, and losing him hurts the team both defensively and offensively on the flank. He has already been absent since April 25, with Nicholas Cavallo absorbing his playing time.

May 2, 2026

Sidelined with leg injury

O'Toole is dealing with a leg injury that makes him unavailable for the time being.

Analysis: O'Toole's has played all minutes in every MLS match this year, so losing him is a huge blow to the team. Nicholas Cavallo could take his place in the starting lineup for the duration of his recovery process. While the full extent of O'Toole's issue is uncertain, he should be expected to regain a major role as soon as he's healthy.